The 10 Most Expensive Magmar Pokémon Cards
Magmar is one of those Pokémon that warms the hearts of collectors with its fiery personality and compelling artwork. Not only does this hot-headed Pokémon have a special place in the hearts of fans from the earlier sets, but it also spans multiple generations of the Pokémon Trading Card Game (TCG). From its humble beginnings in base sets to its status as a sought-after collectible, Magmar's various printings reflect the ever-evolving landscape of the TCG market. Prices are driven by nostalgia, rarity, and the stunning artwork that brings this Pokémon to life, making it a must-have for many collectors.
Browse every Magmar card ever printed
View all Magmar cards across every set with live prices
The Magmar from Team Rocket Returns (#44) is a beast in the market, fetching around $79.99 for its Reverse Holofoil variant. This card is a true gem from a set that is often considered a collector's holy grail. The beautiful artwork features Magmar in a striking pose, and its rarity as an Uncommon card makes it even more coveted. With supply being relatively low due to the age of the set and strong demand from nostalgia-driven collectors, this fiery Pokémon has earned its place at the top.
Buy on TCGPlayer
Next up, we have the Magmar ex from the Ruby & Sapphire set, priced around $53.52 for its Holofoil variant. This card marked the introduction of the EX mechanic, which instantly boosted its appeal. The artwork is vibrant, capturing Magmar's fiery essence beautifully. Being a Rare Holo EX adds to its collector value, making it a hot item for both competitive players and collectors alike. The combination of nostalgia and playability makes it a fantastic addition to any collection.
The Magmar from the Expedition Base Set (#86) holds its ground at approximately $38.43 for the Reverse Holofoil version. This card showcases stunning artwork that captures Magmar's fiery spirit, set against a backdrop that highlights its Pokémon lore. As an Uncommon, it’s less accessible than other Magmar cards, pushing prices up. The Expedition set is noteworthy for its unique card design and collector appeal, making this Magmar a notable find for both nostalgic fans and savvy investors.
Hitting the charts at around $24.20 is the Magmar from Legend Maker (#21), a Rare card that flaunts a captivating Reverse Holofoil design. This set is revered for its unique mechanics and special cards, so having a Magmar here boosts its desirability. The artwork is charming, and being a Rare card makes it a collector's dream. As collectors seek to complete their Legend Maker sets, this Magmar’s price will likely continue to heat up—pun intended!
The Wizards Black Star Promo Magmar is a nostalgia trip priced at about $22.25. This card stands out as a Promo, often less available than regular set cards, adding to its allure. The artwork features a classic-looking Magmar that many collectors grew up with. Its popularity remains strong, driven by both its unique status and the love for promo cards from the early TCG days. Collectors often scramble to grab this card, making it a solid investment.
The Magmar from the Pokémon TCG Classic - Charizard set sits at around $10.70 for its Holofoil variant. Though not as pricey as some of its counterparts, it features a nostalgic design that pulls at the heartstrings of collectors. The 'Classic' branding gives it an edge, while the lack of rarity classification keeps it accessible. This makes it a great entry point for new collectors looking to snag a piece of history without breaking the bank.
At a friendly $10.50, the Magmar from HS—Triumphant (#42) offers a Reverse Holofoil that captures the vibrant nature of this fiery Pokémon. The artwork pops with color and captures a dynamic pose that resonates with fans. As an Uncommon, it's somewhat more available, but collectors recognize the set's charm and significance, leading to steady demand. This card is a nice blend of affordability and collectibility, making it a solid pick for any Magmar enthusiast.
The 2019 McDonald’s Collection Magmar holds its ground at around $10.15, and this Holofoil version adds a touch of nostalgia for those who remember the fast-food promotion. The artwork is cute and reminiscent of the playful nature of the Pokémon series. While its rarity is still somewhat unknown, the limited availability from the promotional event boosts its desirability. It’s a quirky piece that appeals to collectors looking for unique cards tied to special promotions.
The Fossil Magmar (#39) in its 1st Edition glory hails at $9.22, making it a nostalgic pick for long-time collectors. As part of the Fossil set, this Uncommon card is steeped in history. The artwork depicts Magmar in a more simplistic style that calls back to the early days of Pokémon TCG. Collectors often seek out 1st Edition cards, which adds a nice layer of value. Though it may not break the bank, it’s a classic that every serious collector should consider.
Lastly, we have Blaine's Magmar from Gym Heroes (#37), priced at around $8.51 for the 1st Edition variant. This Uncommon card features a unique artwork showcasing Blaine's own Magmar, which brings in the trainer aspect that fans adore. Its connection with the Gym Leader adds a story element that boosts its appeal. While it may not be the priciest Magmar on the list, it’s a must-have for those looking to complete their Gym Hero collection.
If you're a Magmar collector or just looking to add some fiery flair to your collection, there’s no better time than now to dive in. While some cards are seeing prices rise, others might still be under the radar. Keep an eye on older sets like Team Rocket Returns and Ruby & Sapphire, as they are likely to appreciate over time thanks to their nostalgia factor and rarity. Just remember: your wallet might cry, but your collection will thank you.
Prices last updated: April 9, 2026 at 10:26 PM UTC
Market prices sourced from TCGPlayer. Affiliate links may earn us a commission at no cost to you.
View all Magmar cards across every set →