The 10 Most Expensive Squirtle Pokémon Cards
Ah, Squirtle — the lovable water type that has been splashing its way into the hearts of Pokémon fans since day one. With its cute, chubby cheeks and classic blue shell, this little guy is not just a starter Pokémon; he's a nostalgia-powered icon that many collectors chase. When it comes to the TCG, Squirtle spans a plethora of sets, from the early days of Base Set to more modern collections, each boasting unique artwork and rarity. Prices for Squirtle cards have surged due to their nostalgic value, rarity, and the sheer cuteness of Squirtle itself, making these aquatic gems highly sought after by both competitive players and collectors alike.
Browse every Squirtle card ever printed
View all Squirtle cards across every set with live prices
The Squirtle from Legendary Collection (#95) is a chase card due to its Reverse Holofoil treatment and iconic reprint status from the original Base set. Going for a cool $409.67, this card is like finding a rare vintage wine at a garage sale. The set is beloved for its nostalgic artwork and unique patterns, making it a must-have for serious collectors. Its limited supply mixed with high demand creates a perfect storm of desirability. Plus, who can resist that adorable face gleaming in the light?
Buy on TCGPlayer
Coming in at $222.94, the FireRed & LeafGreen Reverse Holofoil Squirtle (#83) is a fan favorite. The set is famous for bringing beloved Kanto Pokémon into the modern era with fresh artwork, and this card shines bright, literally. Its rarity as a common card in such a beloved set drives demand. Additionally, it appeals to collectors who appreciate the nostalgia factor of the original Pokémon games, making it a prime target for anyone looking to add a slice of Kanto history to their collection.
The Expedition Base Set Reverse Holofoil Squirtle (#132) is worth an impressive $153.64, mainly due to its unique artwork and the set's status as one of the first e-Reader expansions. This card stands out with its vibrant colors and charming pose, perfectly capturing Squirtle's playful spirit. As a common card, it’s surprisingly collectible, drawing in both nostalgic fans and new collectors who appreciate the distinct e-Card mechanics. It’s the kind of investment that makes you feel good every time you see it in your binder.
At $132.50, the FireRed & LeafGreen (#82) Reverse Holofoil Squirtle is another jewel. This card features a classic Squirtle pose that captures its innocent charm, making it irresistible for many collectors. Its higher price tag is a result of the card's nostalgic appeal and the limited print runs of the FireRed & LeafGreen sets. As a common card, it’s a testament to how demand can elevate even the simplest Pokémon to collector's item status. Your wallet may not thank you, but your collection certainly will!
The Team Magma vs Team Aqua Squirtle (#46) is priced at $126.32, and it’s easy to see why. This card stands out with its unique artwork that channels the rivalry between the two teams, giving Squirtle a cool edge that many fans adore. As a common card, it's surprisingly valuable thanks to limited print runs and the set's popularity among collectors. If you want a Squirtle that embodies both nostalgia and a bit of drama, this card is a must-have before it splashes out of your price range.
Valued at $119.60, the Stellar Crown Squirtle (#148) takes the cake as an Illustration Rare. This card features a gorgeous holofoil finish that makes it pop under any light, and its artwork is simply stunning, showcasing Squirtle in a way that feels fresh and vibrant. The rarity and quality of Illustration Rares have made them a hot commodity in recent years, and this card is no exception. It’s like the crème de la crème of Squirtle cards — pure eye candy for collectors.
The Holofoil Squirtle from the 151 (#170) set, priced at $102.46, is another shining example of the little blue turtle's appeal. This newer card is packed with nostalgic charm while also being a fresh take on the character. The set itself has gained traction among collectors, mostly because of its hype and connection to original Pokémon lore. It’s a beautiful addition to your collection, especially if you’re looking to balance nostalgia with something a bit more modern.
Coming in at $102.40, the Crystal Guardians Reverse Holofoil Squirtle (#64) has that gorgeous artwork that can turn any casual fan into a collector. This card showcases artistic flair while keeping that classic Squirtle charm intact. Its price is driven by the limited print runs and demand for nostalgia-infused cards, making it a solid investment. Plus, who wouldn’t want a Squirtle that looks like it just jumped out of a watercolor painting? It’s practically art you can hold.
The Expedition Base Set Squirtle (#131), valued at $77.50, is another Reverse Holofoil that deserves a place in your collection. While it may not be as pricey as its counterparts, its unique artwork from this e-Reader set captures a nostalgic moment that resonates with many collectors. As a common card, it’s accessible, but that doesn’t mean it lacks charm or value. It’s an excellent entry point for new collectors looking to dive into the Squirtle market without breaking the bank.
Last but certainly not least, the HS—Unleashed Squirtle (#63) comes in at a modest $54.96. This Reverse Holofoil showcases Squirtle in a dynamic pose that grabs attention. While it's the least expensive on this list, its artwork and connection to the HeartGold & SoulSilver series give it significance. With a growing appreciation for older sets, this card is likely to see appreciation over time. For anyone looking to start or expand their Squirtle collection without burning a hole in their pocket, this is a solid choice.
The market for Squirtle cards is ripe with possibilities, especially with the nostalgia factor driving many collectors to the edge of their wallets. Right now could be a decent time to buy, especially if you’re eyeing the mid-range cards that haven’t spiked yet. Keep an eye out for cards from sets like Expedition and FireRed & LeafGreen, as they seem to be on the rise. But remember, as with any collectible, do your research. Happy collecting — may your binder overflow with adorable water turtles!
Prices last updated: April 9, 2026 at 10:26 PM UTC
Market prices sourced from TCGPlayer. Affiliate links may earn us a commission at no cost to you.
View all Squirtle cards across every set →